Can i use gpl libraries in a closed source project if only. Jul 02, 2015 top 10 gpl license questions answered. The license was originally written by richard stallman, former head of the free software foundation fsf, for. Using the ordinary gpl for a library gives free software developers an advantage over proprietary developers. Four years ago, i interviewed nathan currulla, cofounder of bywater solutions, a major services and solutions provider for koha, a popular open source integrated library system ils. At what point does a gpllicensed library become incorporated into my proprietary program so as to require my program to be distributed under the gpl. Distributing a proprietary application together with gpl.
A practical guide to gpl compliance software freedom law. When you want to use a free software library or framework for building a proprietary product, its important to examine exactly which free software licence the library or framework is. Cool gpl software loses out on all the manpower that could have been given to it by proprietary software makers. Postgresql about gpl and proprietary software grokbase. Propietary modules within gpl and bsd kernels closed ask question. The gnu lesser general public license lgpl is a free software license published by the free software foundation fsf. By contrast, the gnu general public license is intended to guarantee your freedom to share and change free software to make sure the software is free for all its users. Lgpllicensed libraries can be linked with nongpl licensed programs, including proprietary software. It is not the intent of the gpl to require you to distribute thirdparty software tools to your customer provided the tools themselves are not based on the gpld software shipped, but we do believe it requires that you give the user all the essential non proprietary facts that you had at your disposal to build the software. That is the consequence of your decision of choosing open source. Apr 15, 2004 this is where the gpl causes a lot of sleepless nights. This has implications for proprietary andor commercial software developers, as many popular and important libraries are licensed under the gpl. Why you shouldnt use the library gpl for your next.
Since then, ive benefitted directly from his companys work, as my local chautauquacattaraugus library system in western new york migrated from a proprietary software system to a bywater solutions koha. Hundreds of large proprietary software companies like the look of the software, and use it, but never open source their changes. Top 9 gpl with the classpath exception questions answered. After purchase, you will receive the login information to access the full version of the ziparchive library with sources and you will have the rights to use both versions of the ziparchive library in proprietary software. Therefore, if you distribute a program linked against a gpl library, you had best be prepared to adhere to the requirements of gpl license. That depends on whether the mysql client library is lgpl up to version 3 or gpl from version 4 on. Frequently asked questions about the gnu licenses gnu. Can i sell a proprietary software with an lgpl library. Its very common for developers to want to use opensource libraries and frameworks. This is why we used the library gpl for the gnu c library.
Can i link to a gpl library from a closed source application. Frequently asked questions about the gnu licenses gnu project. Bruce perens on combining gpl and proprietary software slashdot. Such formats and protocols may be restricted as trade secrets or subject to patents. The licenses were originally written by richard stallman, former head of the free software foundation fsf, for the gnu project, and grant the recipients of a computer program the rights of the free software. This includes all free software licenses, as well as all proprietary software licenses. However, it is often possible to include the gpl code in an entirely separate program separate. Gpl program is infecting and infected the parent and the child non gpl process proprietary and even other open source license from the perspective of law. You can distribute your application using a gpl library commercially, but you must also provide the source code. You can use lgpl libraries in your proprietary code and distribute without having to open source your proprietary code. The lgpl provides an alternative license that preserves many of the benefits of the gpl model for such librariesin fact, the lesser general public license was in its first incarnation known as the library general public license.
Use a gpl package in a proprietary licensed software ros. In fact, libraries with open source integrated systems report the same levels of satisfaction as those using proprietary products, according to the perceptions 2016 survey on library automation. List of free and opensource software packages wikipedia. Understanding open source and free software licensing. Gnu general public license this license, commonly known as the gpl, has two versions that are actively and widely used in many open source communities. For proprietary software, code under the lgpl is usually used in the form of a shared library, so that there is a clear separation between the proprietary and lgpl components. So although you can use your combination of gpl program and proprietary license, you cannot convey or distribute the gpl program without the proprietary library, unless that proprietary library is a system library. Its impressive, for instance, to look at sonys web site where they fulfill their gpl obligation, and see the dozens of tv models and many other products that contain linux. This means that any software that is written based on any gpl component must be released as open source. Differences between gpl and lgpl when using licensed software. Gpl vs bsd, a matter of sustainability hacker news. Jan, 2016 the effect of the gpl with classpath exception is similar. The osis work, and thus funding support, focuses on the creation and curation of resources that enable, promote, and protect open source software development, adoption, and communities. It is therefore often thought that gpl licensed software is unsuitable for proprietary projects.
If youre just using a distributed multinode system inside your company, then youre entirely in the clear, as yan says. If you are trying to use a proprietary driver on linux, then yes, this should be allowed. Then assume a customized mainstream linux distribution, with visible trademarked logos etc removed. The distinction between the various functions is not entirely clearcut. Open source library software s does not need the initial cost of commercial software and. The lgpl is intended to be a license for libraries. In fact, as we argued in previous posts, open source software may sometimes be safer than proprietary software since you have more people checking and fixing problems. As sticky as the issue is, there is an answer, as self titled open source strategic consultant bruce perens exp. This is a list of links to articles on software used to manage portable document format pdf documents. Gpl warrants heightened attention searchdatacenter. Why you should use a bsd style license for your open source. Is there a loophole in the gpl that allows proprietary.
If you have licensed software youve written under gpl version 2, and you are the original licensor of that software, you may wish to relicense your software under gpl version 3. Open source software is, software that users have the ability to run, copy, distribute, study, change, share and improve for any purpose. This article by jerry epplin sheds some light on the issues associated with using gpl software in. But there are some cases i would like to make myself clear. Open source software and libraries sukhwinder randhawa abstract. Using open source libraries with closed source software. The main idea here is that the library remains free software. I want to modify the heck out of this software to create my own web site application.
You cannot incorporate gplcovered software in a proprietary system. See the mariadb licensing faq, which also applies to mysql, for more details and advice. There are some variations of the gpl, the most notable being the lesser gpl, which allows other software including proprietary software to use the source code normally a utility library of some. The goal of the gpl is to grant everyone the freedom to copy, redistribute, understand, and modify a program. Can i link a gpl program with a proprietary system library. This is software that publishes websites and web pages. Distributing in this sense means giving or selling to customers. Does gpl code linking with proprietary library depend. Incorporating gpllicensed code in proprietary programs a key question that arises when using gpl licensed software with proprietary programs is. What legal issues come up if i use gplincompatible libraries with gpl software. This is why we used the lesser gpl for the gnu c library. Gpl software certification program free software foundation.
I understand that so is not a place for lawyers so im just interesting in have you ever used gpl library for writing non gpl software. Hello, if i need to include nodes from a gpl licensed package e. Perens represented open source at the united nations world summit on the information society, at the request of the united nations development program. The license allows developers and companies to use and integrate a software component released under the lgpl into their own even proprietary software without being required by the terms of a strong copyleft license to release the source code of their own components. What i am particulary interested in is when does gpl license become restrictive. Stallman admits gpl flawed, proprietary licensing needed to. Infecting means derived program violate gpl, infected means gpl program violate its own license. May 27, 2016 as noted, inclusion of a gpllicensed library in a proprietary program does not automatically render the proprietary program subject to the gpl, but it would be a breach of the librarys gpl licence to distribute the proprietary program under a nongpl licence. Richard stallman and others are trying to block oracles acquisition of mysql. Modifications to gpl source code bring a broad definition of a derivative work into play. Linking against a gpled library will make your program a derived work and you will be required to license it under the gpl. The lgpl is primarily used for software libraries, although it is also used by some standalone applications. This resulted in a modified version of the gpl called the lgpl library, since renamed to lesser, gpl. This page is maintained by the free software foundations licensing and compliance lab.
You can support our efforts by making a donation to the fsf. The gnu general public license gnu gpl or gpl is a series of widely used free software licenses that guarantee end users the freedom to run, study, share, and modify the software. But if the previous is true then that would indicate that no person or organization could ever release any proprietary software on linux ever. The gnu general public license gnu gpl or gpl is a series of widely used free software. Gnu general public license, version 2 spdx short identifier. As mentioned in other answers, for gpl license just linking is not enough. Gpl, also known as copyleft, grants permission to reuse or modify the source code to make derivative works, but if you distribute your program to others, it requires you to license your derivative work under the gpl too. Have you ever used gpl library for writing nongpl software. Why you shouldnt use the lesser gpl for your next library. In that case, the library cannot give free software any particular advantage, so it is better to use the library gpl for that library. This is a list of free and opensource software packages, computer software licensed under free software licenses and opensource licenses. It means that the source code of the application must be provided. If proprietary library is created first such as windows dlls that is published without linking and any gpl code and later a gpl program is linked with it, then the gpl program cant convert the proprietary library into gpl although the proprietary code is linked with the gpl code.
For example say a company has a proprietary software product that only works with mysql and no other database system. Frequently answered questions open source initiative. Richard stallman and the fsf specifically encourage library writers to license under the gpl so that proprietary programs cannot use the libraries. A proprietary application programming interface api is a software library. Software that fits the free software definition may be more appropriately called free software. The expense of this is a business decision to be considered. Clause 4 of the gpl states that such a breach automatically terminates the licence. Why gpl violations are bad gary explains android authority. The lgpl exists to allow the creation of free software that can be linked to proprietary code without having to release the proprietary code. The gpl, lgpl, and mozilla licenses understanding open. Your proprietary program can then call that program, and give it e. However, there are cases when gplcovered software can be distributed alongside a proprietary system.
By 1990, it was becoming apparent that a less restrictive license would be strategically useful for the c library and for software libraries that essentially did the job of existing proprietary ones. This information allows us to check for the following issues. Proprietary software often citation needed stores some of its data in file formats which are incompatible with other software, and may also communicate using protocols which are incompatible. Such applications often must link with system libraries. The gpl the gnu general public license the most popular copyleft licence, sometimes gets a hostile press, often for reasons that. Gpl is a copyleft license so it requires derivative works to be released under the same license and programs linked with a library released under the gpl must also be released under the gpl. Can i use gpl libraries in a closed source project if only the output. Oct 22, 2009 stallman admits gpl flawed, proprietary licensing needed to pay for mysql development.
The gnu general public license gnu gpl or gpl is a widelyused free software license, which guarantees end users the freedom to run, study, share and modify the software. In that case, the library cannot give free software any particular advantage, so it is better to use the lesser gpl for that library. Mar 05, 2001 using gpl software in embedded applications. Using gpllicensed components in proprietary projects. Software licensed under the gnu general public license is free software, and all software that builds on gpl licensed components is also free and must also be licensed under the gpl. The legal problem law raise when you do an act of distributing gpl program as binary or library on non gpl os. The most common case is when a free library s features are readily available for proprietary software through other libraries.
The gpl itself defines a system library in words that are somewhat incomprehensible to a nonlawyer. If you just use it personally or within your organization, the gpl doesnt really affect you. The free software foundation fsf is a nonprofit with a worldwide mission to promote computer. You create a derived work when you mingle your proprietary source code with the gpl code. Pressure to put proprietary applications on linux became overwhelming. Horowhenua library trust named the system koha, which is a new zealand maori custom meaning gift or contribution. A practical guide to gpl compliance software freedom law center. Does gpl code linking with proprietary library depend which. Proprietary software developers have the advantage of money. This is a story of why we developed koha and how it has changed the way we, and millions of others, work. Why you shouldnt use the library gpl for your next library. While proprietary software remains the dominant approach, a growing percentage of libraries are adopting open source products. A gpl linking exception modifies the gnu general public license gpl in a way that enables software projects which provide library code to be linked to the. The osi cannot directly fund your open source software project, we fund projects that raise awareness and adoption of your open source software project.
What is the difference between gpl, agpl and lgpl licenses. Choosing open source is fine, but when you talk about your proprietary code it seems like you never even considered the requirements from your end in the case of gpl and lgpl. Software licensed with any gnu license can be used and modified everywhere, without any restrictions in private and even in corporate environments. About gpl and proprietary software postgresql database. Aug 31, 2018 differences between gpl and lgpl when using licensed software. If gpl code is in an application, the free software foundation doesnt care if its a static link or a dynamic link to a gpl library for example.
For example you can use the mariadb client library, which is lgpld and is thus compatible with proprietary software and provides the same api of the original mysql client library. The most common case is when a free library s features are readily available for proprietary software through other alternative libraries. It seems that a company is capable of designing a proprietary program to use a gpl library without violating the gpl, so long as a wrapper module is used to insulate the proprietary program from the gpl library and that module is distributed separately. Proprietary software sormec marine and offshore cranes. Can software that modifies a library under gnu gpl be sold. However, im being told that i can not use this software and create my own proprietary software since the code im looking at that was originally licensed under the gnu gpl. I understand that so is not a place for lawyers so im just interesting in have you ever used gpl library for writing nongpl software. The lgpl and gpl licenses differ with one major exception. Can libraries licensed with gplv2 be used in proprietary applications.
As long as you ensure that the plugin is not dynamically linked, you can share your software under a proprietary licence and distribute the plugin under the free licence. This general public license applies to most of the free software foundations software and to any other program whose authors commit to using it. The gpl wont infect your proprietary software unless you link to it. A small public library serving a population of 30,000 in new zealand developed and released the worlds first open source library management system in 2000.
This article by jerry epplin sheds some light on the issues associated with using gpl software in embedded applications, and attempts to dispel the. Assume a proprietary linux application, which links against lgpl libraries dynamically, and does not link against gpl libraries. Software licensed under the gnu general public license is free software, and all software that builds on gpllicensed components is also free and must also be licensed under the gpl. If you want to use something covered by a stricter licence, like the gnu gpl, you can use the gnu gpl library as part of a plugin that connects with your primary proprietary software. If an application links to a library licensed under gpl, it must also be licensed under gpl.
Under gplv2, you are obligated to distribute all source code when you publish the work. The lgpl allows proprietary code to be linked to the gnu c library, glibc. The mpl and gpl with classpath exception have certain other differences, outside the scope of this faq. Oct 10, 2011 the gnu gpl general public license covers over 50% of the free software projects including the linux kernel, busybox and many applications. Aug 26, 2008 these requirements are carefully designed to uphold certain values and standards of the software freedom community. Can i use gpl libraries in a closed source project if only the output is distributed. It is therefore often thought that gpllicensed software is unsuitable for proprietary projects. Software licenses will either get in the way of this full ownership as proprietary ones often do or facilitate full ownership as opensource ones often do. Apr 22, 2020 you may copy, distribute and modify the software as long as you track changesdates of in source files and keep modifications under gpl. Therefore, if you distribute a program linked against a gpl library, you had best be prepared to adhere to the. While the gpls requirements may appear initially counterintuitive to those more familiar with proprietary software licenses, by comparison its terms are in fact clear and favorable to licensees.
343 321 738 346 1159 1478 408 133 1145 794 1517 245 1048 724 130 566 597 69 653 925 1337 130 1511 1312 679 277 398 619 1455 195 216 1433 1292 727 1376 433 810 454 1192 553 1189 74 74 439 1405 1184 271 169 1111